Netflix's newest historical drama Death By Lightning has captivated audiences across Canada, consistently ranking near the top spot on the streaming platform's most-watched list. This four-part series delivers a compelling examination of one of American history's most dramatic political assassinations.
The Tragic Story of President James Garfield
The series focuses on the rapid political ascent and even swifter demise of President James Garfield, portrayed by Michael Shannon. Garfield secured the Republican nomination at the 1880 Republican National Convention and began his presidency with great promise, only to have his term cut tragically short.
On July 2, 1881, merely months into his presidency, Garfield was shot by Charles Guiteau, a disillusioned supporter who had sought a position within the administration. The president ultimately succumbed to his injuries in September of that year, with the series exploring the medical mishandling that contributed to his death.
Stellar Cast Brings History to Life
Matthew Macfadyen delivers an extraordinary performance as Charles Guiteau, capturing the delusional nature of the failed lawyer who turned assassin. Macfadyen channels some of the unpredictable energy that Succession fans will recognize from his portrayal of Tom Wambsgans, creating a complex and unsettling character.
The supporting cast shines equally bright. Nick Offerman appears as Vice President Chester Arthur, who reluctantly assumes the presidency following Garfield's death. Michael Shannon brings strength and depth to his portrayal of Garfield, while Betty Gilpin stands out as the president's wife, Lucretia, delivering a powerful speech to Guiteau as he awaits execution.
The ensemble extends to include Shea Whigham as powerful New York figure Roscoe Conkling, Bradley Whitford as Secretary of State James G. Blaine, and Vondie Curtis-Hall in a recurring role as abolitionist Frederick Douglass. Shaun Parkes appears as Dr. Charles Purvis, the Black physician who provided immediate care to Garfield after the shooting.
Historical Accuracy Meets Engaging Storytelling
What makes Death By Lightning particularly compelling is its ability to transform a dark historical moment into an educational and surprisingly engaging experience. The series manages to incorporate moments of humor while never losing sight of the tragedy at its core.
The production delves into the medical controversies surrounding Garfield's treatment, highlighting how infection ultimately caused the president's death rather than the gunshot wound itself. The series shows how Garfield's doctor, Willard Bliss, disregarded emerging research about antiseptics, with scenes that viewers will find particularly frustrating.
At just four episodes, the mini-series proves the perfect length to fully immerse viewers in this historical period without overstaying its welcome. The concise format has drawn praise from audiences who appreciate the focused storytelling and lack of filler content.
Audience and Critical Reception
Canadian viewers and social media users have enthusiastically embraced the series. One Twitter user noted: "Watched #deathbylightning yesterday and highly recommend! The political nerd in me loved learning about this often forgotten bit of history. Wonderful actors and fantastically made."
Another viewer commented on the series' surprising blend of tones: "#DeathByLightning is terrific. Historically accurate, and some fantastic performances. Also, surprisingly funny, until obviously it turns very dark."
The casting has received particular acclaim, with one social media user observing: "Matthew Macfadyen and Michael Shannon are simply BRILLIANT in #DeathByLightning! Shannon perfectly plays a stoic and warm-hearted Garfield and Macfadyen plays the dastardly lout Guiteau so magnificently."
The series has drawn comparisons to premium television, with one viewer describing it as: "If Succession and There Will Be Blood had a baby in 1881 D.C. — it'd be Netflix's new mini series 'Death by Lightning'. This is the kind of prestige TV that has 'watch in one-sitting' written all over it."
Death By Lightning successfully demonstrates how limited series can make significant impact without extended episode counts, offering Canadian audiences a perfect blend of historical education and entertainment that leaves viewers both informed and satisfied.
