In a major blow to DC Studios, the highly anticipated 'Supergirl' film starring Milly Alcock opened to a disappointing $28 million at the domestic box office over its first weekend, far behind Pixar's 'Toy Story 5,' which debuted with $120 million. The superhero film's underperformance raises questions about the viability of DC's expanded universe strategy.
Box Office Disparity
According to studio estimates released Sunday, 'Toy Story 5' dominated the weekend, attracting families and nostalgia-driven audiences. 'Supergirl' managed only a fraction of that, placing second. Industry analysts had projected a $40-50 million opening for 'Supergirl,' making the actual result a significant disappointment.
"This is a tough start for DC," said box office analyst Paul Dergarabedian. "'Supergirl' needed to prove that audiences are still invested in this universe, and the numbers suggest otherwise."
Critical Reception
Reviews for 'Supergirl' were mixed, with a 54% score on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics praised Alcock's performance but criticized the film's convoluted plot and uneven tone. In contrast, 'Toy Story 5' received a 92% fresh rating, with many calling it a heartfelt return to form for Pixar.
Impact on DC Studios
The film's weak opening is a setback for DC Studios co-heads James Gunn and Peter Safran, who are attempting to reboot the franchise. 'Supergirl' was intended to be a cornerstone of their new slate. The studio now faces pressure to reassess its upcoming releases, including 'The Batman Part II' and 'Superman: Legacy.'
"DC can't afford many more misses like this," said media analyst Sarah Whitten. "They need to build momentum, and this doesn't help."
International Performance
Overseas, 'Supergirl' earned $35 million from 60 markets, bringing its global total to $63 million. 'Toy Story 5' added $100 million internationally for a $220 million global debut. The disparity underscores the challenges DC faces in competing with Disney's powerhouse brands.
Warner Bros. declined to comment on the film's performance or future plans.
