Former That '70s Show star Danny Masterson is mounting a vigorous legal challenge to overturn his two rape convictions and the 30-year prison sentence he is currently serving. The actor has filed a petition alleging he received an inadequate defence from his original trial lawyer, a claim that could grant him a new trial if successful.
Grounds for the Appeal: Ineffective Assistance of Counsel
In a formal petition for habeas corpus submitted to California’s 2nd District Court of Appeal, Masterson's new legal team argues that his previous lawyer, Philip Cohen, provided a deficient defence. They claim Cohen failed to contact and call upon numerous witnesses whose testimonies could have supported Masterson's claim of innocence.
The court documents, which include 65 exhibits, allege that at least 20 potential witnesses were not utilized during the trial. Masterson's new attorney, Eric Multhaup, stated that the jury only heard the prosecution's side of the story. The defence evidence that was available, including accounts from individuals who reportedly heard what they believed was consensual activity, was never presented.
The Role of Scientology and Alleged Bias
The petition also contends that Masterson's membership in the Church of Scientology unfairly became a central focus of the trial. His lawyers argue that the prosecution aggressively presented evidence related to Scientology and that the trial judge demonstrated a bias against the organization.
Furthermore, the filing points to an inappropriate entanglement between the prosecution and Leah Remini, a prominent critic of Scientology. Masterson's team asserts that this combination of factors—prosecutorial misconduct, judicial bias, and his own lawyer's failure to mount a proper defence—led to an unfair trial.
Background of the Case and Lasting Impact
Danny Masterson was convicted in 2025 for the rape of two women at his Hollywood Hills home in 2003, during the peak of his fame on That '70s Show. Following a mistrial in his first court proceeding, the second trial resulted in a conviction and a sentence of 30 years to life in prison.
During his sentencing, the profound impact of his actions was highlighted by his victims. One woman told the court that Masterson had stolen her spirit, while another noted he had shown no remorse. The jury was unable to reach a verdict on a third rape charge involving a longtime girlfriend.
The legal filing arrives amid significant personal changes for Masterson. His ex-wife, Bijou Phillips, filed for divorce after his conviction and has recently sought court permission to remove Masterson's surname from their daughter's name.
While this habeas corpus petition moves forward, Masterson's main appeal continues to work its way through the California court system, leaving his future uncertain.
