In an era marked by destructive politics and fractured communication, Alberta's upcoming vote on a secession referendum threatens to deepen societal divides. Keith Gerein, in a recent column, emphasizes that honesty between opposing factions may be the key to weathering this political storm.
Breakdown of the Social Contract
Over recent months, Gerein has observed a growing breakdown in the social contract, with more people recognizing the trend and sometimes falling victim to it. The cracks are both obvious and subtle, ranging from local incidents—such as Edmontonians threatening city snow-clearing crews—to the everyday grift and nihilism displayed by political leaders. This abandonment of basic virtues like respect, empathy, fairness, and fidelity to the rule of law sets a troubling stage for the Oct. 19 vote on a secession referendum.
Optimism vs. Concern
Some maintain optimism, noting that Albertans and Canadians have weathered many crises. Others are less buoyant, pointing to a far more disruptive communication ecosystem. Unlike past crises, today's challenges include a juggernaut of fear and misinformation fueled by social media and nefarious AI. Managing differences in opinion is now compounded by differences in perceived reality.
Gerein worries about the potential for destructiveness as more people untether from societal norms. Secession itself threatens quality of life, but even platforming the question can be harmful. However, since Premier Danielle Smith appears determined to force Albertans down this path, Gerein argues that survival depends on honesty between opposing sides.
A Call for Honest Dialogue
This column is an attempt at such honesty. Gerein expresses willingness to listen to those who favour separation, hoping others will do the same, as Albertans are stuck with each other regardless of the outcome. Listening leads to understanding, which eases the path to détente. However, Gerein clarifies that his curiosity does not mean he will ever be swayed. He defines himself as both Canadian and Albertan, holding these identities as indistinguishable. If forced to choose, his reaction is instinctive resistance.
Gerein admits that even if he could be swayed, the separatist camp has offered almost nothing impressive so far.
