Prime Minister Mark Carney stated that new Canadians who have been instructed to surrender their citizenship documents deserve clear answers, addressing growing concerns over the policy. The comments come amid reports that some new citizens have been asked to hand over their citizenship certificates or other official documents, causing confusion and distress.
Background of the Issue
The requirement appears to stem from administrative processes related to immigration and citizenship verification. However, affected individuals have reported receiving conflicting instructions from government offices, with some being told the documents are needed for record-keeping or security checks, while others have been left without explanation.
According to a spokesperson for Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC), the department is reviewing the situation to ensure consistency and clarity. The spokesperson emphasized that citizenship documents are the property of the individual and should not be surrendered arbitrarily.
Political Reaction
Carney's remarks were made during a press conference on June 25, 2026, as the spring session of Parliament concluded. He acknowledged the anxiety felt by new Canadians and promised that his government would provide answers. “These individuals have made Canada their home, and they deserve to know why they are being asked to give up their documents,” Carney said.
Opposition critics have seized on the issue, accusing the government of mishandling citizenship processes. Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel Garner called for an immediate investigation, stating that “new Canadians should not be treated as suspects.”
Impact on New Canadians
Community organizations have reported an increase in calls from worried immigrants. Some have expressed fear that surrendering documents could lead to loss of citizenship status or difficulties in travel and employment. A survey by the Canadian Immigrant Settlement Coalition found that 62% of new Canadians are unaware of their rights regarding citizenship documents.
Legal experts note that while the government can request documents for verification, individuals are generally not required to permanently surrender them. The Canadian Civil Liberties Association has urged the government to issue clear guidelines to prevent unnecessary stress.
Government Response
Carney did not specify whether the policy would be changed but indicated that his office is working with IRCC to address the matter. “We will ensure that every new Canadian understands what is required and why,” he said. The prime minister also reiterated Canada’s commitment to welcoming immigrants and protecting their rights.
As of now, no formal directive has been issued to halt the document requests. However, IRCC has stated that it will provide additional training to staff to avoid mixed messages.
