Defence Claims #MeToo Movement Skewed Justice in Stronach Trial
In a high-profile sexual assault trial, the defence for billionaire Frank Stronach has launched a fiery argument, asserting that the #MeToo movement has resulted in an unjust prosecution. Leora Shemesh, Stronach's lawyer, contended in her closing remarks that police failed to conduct proper investigations, instead taking accusers' claims at face value due to societal pressures.
Shift in Burden of Proof Alleged
Shemesh argued that the principle of "Believe women" has been taken to an extreme, undermining constitutional standards. She stated, "The pendulum has swung so far the other way that we’ve lost our ability to balance and respect our constitutional norms." According to her, this has shifted the burden of proof to the accused, with Stronach, 93, being presumed guilty rather than innocent in the case involving allegations from the 1970s and 1980s.
Criticism of Police Investigation
The defence heavily criticized Peel Regional Police for what she described as a lack of corroboration. Shemesh claimed that officers did not verify the women's stories, leading to unreliable accusations. Superior Court Justice Anne Molloy echoed concerns, questioning the police's approach and noting, "They just assume she’s telling the truth," in reference to one complainant.
Discrediting Accusers' Credibility
Shemesh targeted the credibility of the accusers, particularly one woman who alleged an incident at a club Stronach owned. The defence presented evidence contradicting her account, including witness testimonies and social media posts suggesting anti-wealth sentiments. Shemesh labeled the story as "unhinged" and possibly motivated by a desire to "Eat the rich." By the trial's end, the Crown had reduced the charges from 12 involving seven women to those related to four complainants.
Ongoing Legal Proceedings
The trial continues with Crown attorney Jelena Vlacic scheduled to deliver her closing arguments. The case highlights broader debates about the impact of social movements on criminal justice, with the defence striving to portray Stronach as a victim of overzealous prosecution.
